Position Paper / European Policy

 

CF Statement to European Parliament, Temp Cttee on Human Genetics
Population (carrier) screening for Cystic Fibrosis

Cystic Fibrosis is the most common inherited life threatening disorder, caused by a defect in one single gene. Although advances in disease management have improved significantly during the past 30 years the life expectancy of CF-patient is reduced – CF children and adults still die prematurely from Cystic Fibrosis.


PRENATAL DIAGNOSIS

Before introduction of prenatal diagnosis, 83% of the Danish CF families stopped reproduction after the diagnosis of a child with cystic fibrosis.
After the introduction of prenatal diagnosis the number of families who chose to have more children after a CF diagnosis increased significantly.

CONCLUSION: Introduction of prenatal diagnosis permitted at-risk families to have more children without the disease. However, responsiblity for making an informed choice should be theirs alone without any coercion whatsoever.


Population screening for Cystic Fibrosis in Denmark

In June 1990 a pilot project was launched in Denmark. 7.400 pregnant women without known risk for CF were offered a carrier test for CF. Of these women, 6.599  (90%) requested testing for cystic fibrosis. 3 couples were found to be at risk of having a child with CF. After genetic councelling all 3 couples requested prenatal diagnosis. One foetus was diagnosed with CF and the couple chose to terminate the pregnancy.

The impact of carrier screening was assessed in terms of anxiety, perception of health, reproductive decisions, etc. in a study:  “Psychological and social impact of carrier screening for cystic fibrosis among pregnant women – a pilot study”. Hans Clausen et al. Clinical Genetics 1996 (copy of article enclosed). Important results of the study were that perception of future health among the tested women did not change. Only 1% of the women tested negative regretted being tested, whilst 92% did not regret the test.

CONCLUSION: Screening for a life threatening disorder like CF is welcomed, used and well accepted among the Danish population without known risk for CF.


KEY POINTS From the Danish CF Association

  • The population’s wish for disease prevention should be listened to and respected. The parents are qualified to make such decisions affecting their own families and lives.

  • The population should be given the option to make a free informed choice following comprehensive genetic counselling - FREE OF CHARGE .

  • CF carrier testing is NOT a question of eugenics: People just want to give their children the best possible start in life.

  • A screening program including genetic counselling will be value neutral due to savings in the CF treatment program.

  • However, coercion is NOT acceptable. The Society should accept the family choice, and the parents should have the right to benefit from tolerance and understanding from other members of the society, even though they would themselves choose different options.


21 April 2001
Danish Cystic Fibrosis Association